The article is written by Paul Monaghan
A few weeks ago, I wrote about the creative benefits of using ND (Neutral Density) filters in photography. This can be viewed here. Although I love ND filters they can require a larger initial investment which could be a barrier for people who want to play around with long exposures photography.
What if there was another option that let you adjust the strength of the light reduction which costs less and still offers decent image quality?
I know it all sounds a little too good to be true and I did try such a filter many years ago, granted a £30 version from eBay and it degraded the sharpness of my images so much I found it was better used as a coaster!
Fast forward many years and K&F Concept were kind enough to send a few of their Variable Neutral Density Filters through my door and I can honestly say I am really surprised at how good they are.
The filters come in two strengths, the ND2-ND32 which offers a 1 to 5 stop adjustment and the ND8-ND128 which offers a 3 to 7 stop adjustment. Both filters come with hard stops on the minimum and maximum settings to stop you going too far and reducing the image quality.
Personally I find the ND8-ND128 offers the better range as it blocks more light allowing smoother water like in this shot with the Sigma sd Quattro H and Sigma 50-100mm f/1.8 DC HSM Art of Luggie Water on a very cold day.
Unlike a traditional ND filter that is made of a piece of glass or resin and blocks a particular amount of light, variable ND filters are made up of two linear/circular polarizer (CPL) filters as you can see via the reflections in this image.
The variable ND filters work by adjusting the polarization of the light as you rotate the front element, This creates a similar effect as a traditional ND for reducing light. They are not exactly neutral though as the CPL filters that make up the ND will be having an effect on your image. To help understand why I took this photograph of the same scene with the CPL filter set to maximum and one without a CPL to demonstrate the difference it can have.
As you can see the CPL filter only lets light travelling in a particular direction enter the lens, blocking out reflections This not only helps add contrast to images by darkening the sky or removing reflections on small items like leaves but can allow you to see past surface reflections into water or even car windows.
I feel CPL filters are one of the most useful filters you can buy as the effect isn’t something that can be replicated in post, but it might not be an effect you always want and unlike a CPL filter that gives you control over this effect the Variable ND filters don’t. K&F Concept does offer a +CPL version of the ND2-ND32 that lets you have control of the CPL effect directly via an extra leaver but sadly there is no ND8-ND128 version.
The first thing I wanted to test with the filters was colour cast, so I grabbed my Sigma sd Quattro H with 50-100mm f1.8 Art and proceeded to create the same image without filters, with a regular ND (Benro 6 stop) and the K&F Concept Variable ND’s which I tested at the minimum and maximum settings.
Surprisingly for me, the weaker ND2-ND32 actually had the strongest colour cast but the good news that both Variable ND’s were consistent throughout the range so it should be an easy fix in post with a slight white-balance tweak.
Next up I wanted to test the sharpness, Sadly I don’t have the Panasonic S1R around anymore to do the 147mp test as I did in my last article but the Sigma sd Quattro H is very good at resolving fine detail and using a longer focal length tends to put a bit more stress on the filters.
I honestly couldn’t see any difference in sharpness between the Variables, regular ND and no filter except for the ND2-ND32 which at the maximum setting did lose a little contrast and sharpness but even with this 100% crop, it’s very slight.
Costing around £55 for the 82mm version’s where a normal ND filter will often cost more than double that. It is hard not to be impressed with how well these are doing considering the cost and I can see me using these for many shots particularly when I want to travel light.
ARE THEY BETTER THAN A TRADITIONAL SET OF ND’S?
Well, that depends on what you are doing. Traditional ND filters will offer better image quality, particularly during very long exposures as they are also designed to block Infrared light that can start to contaminate the scene and let’s not forget a truly neutral light reduction without any CPL effect unless you add one into the mix. There are also the square filter kits that offer many more options of filter types like graduated filters giving much more control over an image. The downside to this system is that it requires a larger investment, extra bag space and longer time required to change filters means it is not so great for fast adjustments.
Variable ND filters, on the other hand, give you around 5 stops of light adjustment in one filter saving time, money and space so it is really up to each user if the compromises are worth the benefits for either system.
I am pleasantly surprised with the K&F Concept Variable ND filters, in particular, the ND8-ND128 as it offers tremendous value for money for anyone wanting to try some long exposure shots or have more control over shutter speeds when shooting video. I wish that they would offer an ND8-ND128+ CPL version as I feel having control over the CPL effect would benefit everyone.
A good tip when buying filters is to get one that fits your largest lens in my case 82mm and use step-up rings to fit the filter onto smaller ones. This also helps if using an ultra-wide as there’s less chance of the lens seeing the frame of the filter.
I hope this has been helpful, any questions feel free to drop them in the comments below and I would love to see what you create with them if you do grab one.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Paul Monaghan is a portrait photographer based just outside of Glasgow, Scotland. You can see more of his work on Instagram and Facebook. This article was also published here and shared with permission.